Darkly comic thriller following the adventures of a young gay couple in Chicago as they try to extort a prominent anti-gay Christian. Sam (Nathan Adloff) has left his partner Aaron (Taylor Reed) behind to attend art school in Chicago. He is short on money, however, and turns to casual prostitution in a bid to gain income. Displeased by this, Aaron joins his lover in the city and determines to make enough money that Sam can give up his vice. When Aaron secretly observes that one of his boyfriend's clients is prominent anti-gay Christian Andrew Kenneth Tucker (Joe Swanberg), a plan is hatched to extort Tucker for the money the boys seek. Unfortunately the plan doesn't go smoothly and the ensuing fall out will test the couple's love to breaking point.