Wealthy Lydia MacMillan (Merle Oberon) is still beautiful as she enters middle age. By chance she meets a former beau, Michael Fitzpatrick (Joseph Cotten), and agrees to take tea in his apartment. When they arrive there Lydia is surprised to see two other former lovers, Bob Willard (George Reeves) and Frank Audry (Hans Yaray). Their talk of old times is disturbed by the arrival of yet another figure from Lydia's past - Richard (Alan Marshal). With her four ex-lovers around her, Lydia looks back and reflects on her life.