If you want to wake up next to a beautiful woman, you need to behave badly on the date the night before; only nice guys sleep alone. Or so high school teacher Carter (Sean O'Bryan) has been led to believe by his best friend Pat and step-sister Erin. Carter has a knack of becoming 'just good friends' with women. So when he meets Maggie on a field trip with his students and asks her out on a date, he decides to ditch the nice guy persona; he turns up late, empty-handed and takes her to a seedy restaurant where he proceeds to tell her that he is not interested in just being friends. Can he carry it off and is Maggie really interested in the new Carter?