Lee Toland Krieger directs this comedy drama about two brothers and one first love. When Caleb (Adam Scott) agrees to drive his younger brother Peter (Alex Frost) and his new girlfriend Emma (Brittany Snow) home for Thanksgiving, his own recent heartbreak begins to rub off on the young lovers. As Caleb hasn't spoken to his father since his mother died, he leaves Peter and Emma and continues on his way. After realising that his brother's new love looks a lot like his ex-girlfriend Hannah (Jordan Reid Berkow), Caleb finds himself uncontrollably drawn to Emma. Is it love, lust or just jealousy?